It happened this past Easter Sunday. Our first child set a new upper limit
for testing parental boundaries, and in the process, threw her Daddy into a
quandary.
Our 4-year-old daughter has certainly told her share of
white lies: "I only watched one 'Curious George.'" "We did wash my hair last night." Those are of no concern. But kid deception
had up until now not been on our radar screens.
Here's how it went down. Mommy was out of the house somewhere with kid #2. Daddy was taking a shower. Things were quiet. Too quiet. I'd heard a door shut, which signals our daughter wants
"to be alone" for a bit.
It usually indicates she's setting up a family in a new Lego home, or
putting together an art show of princess drawings. We're fortunate in that she's very independent and
imaginative. She'll latch on to a
project of her own invention and be good for an hour or two, easy.
When I emerged from the bathroom, she had just exited her
bedroom. She was using both her
arms to cradle her oversize Easter basket, while her right hand was balled up
in a fist, concealing something. When
she saw me, she got deer-caught-in-headlight eyes.
"What's up?" I asked.
"Nothing," she said. She quickly made her way to a garbage can and deposited the
contents of her hand.
I figured the key to this little mystery was now inside that
can, so I checked it out. Bingo: two candy wrappers -- both from
chocolate items.
Now we're certainly not an anti-candy household. In fact, if our children decide to apply
the "lead by example" theory to the eating habits of Mom and Dad,
they'll both be quite familiar with dentists' offices a little ways down the
road.
Plus it was Easter Sunday, for crying out loud. She had just found her basket hidden in
a closet earlier that day, filled with plastic eggs, candy, and a new pair of
pink ballet slippers. We have a
place where her candy intake from parties, Halloween, etc. goes, and her Easter
haul hadn't yet made the trip.
So there it all was -- gummies, jellybeans and chocolate
bunnies -- staring at her from that big basket, in a room with no brother,
Mommy or Daddy present. It doesn't
matter if you're a kid or an adult -- feasting on Easter candy on Easter Day is
what you're supposed to do.
I think what bothered me was that her inclination was to suppress
the fact that she had just chowed some chocolate, instead of simply saying,
"I just had some candy from my Easter basket, and it tasted good!"
But then I realized something. On any other day, our daughter would ask for a treat and we'd okay it, typically waiting until after a meal to give it to her. She doesn't have candy every day, but when she
does, we have a limit for it, and she knows what it is. My wife and I knew that rule was waived
for Easter, but our daughter didn't.
That's likely why she chose to hide the snack.
I wouldn't go so far as to say her reticence hurt my
feelings, but it did trigger some thoughts about how the nature of my
relationship with my daughter could evolve. What I'd like is a completely open forum: Any problem you have, kid, Dad can
handle, or at least give an opinion.
What also struck me was that it was a clear sign of what might
be around the corner. I flashed
back to my own deceptions and lies when I was young. They weren't excessive, but they were also not my finest
moments.
Then I flashed forward, to what my daughter might keep from
Mom and Dad: a bad-for-her
boyfriend, busting curfew, sneaking booze. Suddenly, I was happy we lived on an upper floor in our
building, so she couldn't use some of her dolls to make a fake kid under the
covers, then slip out a window.
I ended up having a chat about honesty with her. I told her that having Easter candy on Easter Day was totally fine. I also told her that she could tell me anything. She said, "Okay." Then I offered her a few jellybeans.
Do you remember the first time your child deceived you?